Home > Common ?'s > Common Questions: “Do Babies Go To Heaven?”

Common Questions: “Do Babies Go To Heaven?”

A friend sent me a list of questions that came up in a small group recently, and asked me to comment on them.  So I have decided to answer their questions here for your benefit as well as the small group’s.  These questions will be put in the category “Common ?’s”

Common Question #1: “Do babies go to heaven?”

Yes, babies go to heaven.  You can see this prove true in two of David’s sons: Absalom and Bathsheba’s baby.  Absalom was not the son a father would want to have.  He was sinful, rebellious, and hateful toward David his father.  He even stole the kingdom away from David at one point in time.  The relationship between David and Absalom was not ideal, to put it mildly.  After a while, Absalom died a horrible death.  Do you recall how David grieved for his son?  He did not jump for joy over losing this awful son of his.  Rather David groaned over the loss of his rebellious son saying, “O my son Absalom, my son, my son Absalom…my son, my son!”  David was heart broken, because he knew he would never see his wicked son again (see 2 Samuel 18:31-33).

Now think of David and Bathsheba’s baby boy.  This boy did not grow up like Absalom did, rather on account of David and Bathsheba’s adultery this baby boy was struck sick from the Lord.  How did David respond?  He fasted and prayed all night long for 7 days asking the Lord to heal and save his boy.  His servants labored to get him to eat, but he would not take any food while his boy was sick.  Then the boy died, and when the servants told David the news of his son’s death David responds in an unusual manner.  He gets up from fasting, washes, anointes himself, changes clothes, and worships the Lord!  The servants were confused and asked David what he was doing, and David replied, “Who knows whether the LORD will be gracious to me, that the child may live?  But now he is dead.  Why should I fast?  Can I bring him back again?  I shall go to him, but he will not return to me.” (see 2 Samuel 12:15-23)

You see the difference in David’s reaction with Absalom’s death and his baby boy’s death?  Why did David act so differently?  Because David expected a personal future reunion with his dead baby boy.  That is why he said “…I shall go to him…” Whereas David did not expect to see Absalom ever again.  ”This is just one indicator of the confidence David had in the goodness and grace of God upon the innocent and the hopelessness of David, knowing the judgment and the justice of God upon the guilty.” (John MacArthur)

Do babies go to heaven?  Yes.

Categories: Common ?'s
  1. Adam Vinson
    November 6, 2009 at 8:38 am | #1

    I am not sure that the two reactions by David are as different as it appears. If you remember David was expecting Bathsheba’s baby to die. God had told him that and David had prayed against it hoping to intervene on his behalf. God saw fit to take the baby as He said and perhaps reality set in for David that the baby was now gone. His grieving took place before the death because he knew the death was coming. Absalom on the other hand had an unexpected death and David now needed to grieve for him. Had he known Absalom’s death was looming he may have reacted the same way he did with Bathsheba’s baby. Instead the grieving had to happen after his death because it was unexpected. The Bible is full of accounts of people grieving over the death of righteous people they know they will see again. David no longer grieves for his child though because he had time to grieve. The grieving process was over. Understand I am not saying that babies don’t go to heaven. I have just never felt like these passages were a good basis to build a theology on the eternal destiny of babies, especially since Absalom isn’t an infant. I’d like to discuss this further sometime.

  2. A. W. Powers
    November 6, 2009 at 10:43 am | #2

    Adam,
    Thanks for your comment man, I always appreciate your words. Where would you go to say that babies go to heaven?

  3. Adam Vinson
    November 8, 2009 at 8:57 pm | #3

    Adam,
    I’ll be honest, I have trouble finding support for it.

  4. A. W. Powers
    November 9, 2009 at 3:07 pm | #4

    Adam,
    Yeah besides the argument I put into the blog, I have trouble finding places as well. Why do you think that is? Are we just trying to prove something that is not Biblical? Or are we really missing the big picture of God’s heart for children within the covenant? Is this an implication of the doctrine of election? What do you think? I think John MacArthurs book “Safe in the Arms of God” would be a good read because he deals with this issue in that book. Have you read it?

  5. Adam Vinson
    November 12, 2009 at 9:47 am | #5

    Adam,
    I struggle with the topic because if I’m honest I admit that God has elected the saints to salvation. Therefore I believe that God in His sovereignty ensures that everything necessary for salvation comes to be. I strongly believe that God ordained me to hear the Gospel at a certain time, pierced my heart and enlightened my eyes through the Holy Spirit, brought conviction to me through the Law, and made me open and whole heartedly receptive to the good news He offered. I believe he has done the same to all those He has chosen and I never wonder or doubt if someone that is “supposed to get saved” will actually get saved. But is it too much to say that not only did God do all the things that I just mentioned, but He also made sure I grew up and lived long enough to have those things done to me? Is it wrong to say that God not only elects people to salvation but He has also elected them to live long enough to receive salvation? Because I have begun to wonder, if babies are all elect and go to heaven, wouldn’t there be more souls in heaven that got in without a conscious decision to follow Christ? Something to think about…I will say that listening to both MacArthur’s and Piper’s arguments have still left me unresolved about it.

  6. A. W. Powers
    November 12, 2009 at 2:17 pm | #6

    “But is it too much to say that not only did God do all the things that I just mentioned, but He also made sure I grew up and lived long enough to have those things done to me?” No it is perfectly praiseworthy and delightful to say such things!

    “Is it wrong to say that God not only elects people to salvation but He has also elected them to live long enough to receive salvation?” DITTO, AMEN!

    “…if babies are all elect and go to heaven, wouldn’t there be more souls in heaven that got in without a conscious decision to follow Christ?” Yes, this is true.

    Since you have read MacArthur and Piper and have not been resolved, WHAT ARE WE TO DO? David’s actions with his baby boy from Bathsheba settle me about this issue. Although I do stop beyond that passage.

  1. No trackbacks yet.